Health insurance for small businesses is expected to go up again next year. Insurers that cover small groups proposed a median increase of 14% for 2027. The main reasons are higher costs for hospital care, doctors, and prescriptions, more people using care, and fewer small businesses in these plans.
If your renewal is coming up, these are the things worth looking at before you sign.
I started my career managing medical offices, and I went back to it after retail, before I moved into HR. Understanding insurance became one of the most useful skills I have. Over the years, I've also worked closely with brokers on plans that were affected by things like location and the makeup of a team, and learned how much a good broker can do to find the right fit.
1Don't just sign the renewal
The renewal your carrier sends is a starting point, not the final offer. Ask your broker to shop it with other carriers and show you a side-by-side comparison. If your broker only ever brings you one option, that's worth a conversation.
2Look at the plan design
There's often room to lower cost without dropping coverage. A few common moves:
- Offer a second, lower-cost plan alongside your current one
- Pair a higher-deductible plan with a health savings account (HSA)
- Consider a plan with a narrower network, if your employees' doctors are in it
Each of these has tradeoffs, so ask your broker to walk you through what they'd mean for your team, not just for your bill.
3Revisit how much you contribute
Many small businesses pay a percentage of the premium. When premiums jump, your cost jumps with them. Some switch to a fixed dollar amount per employee, so the budget is predictable. Whatever you choose, decide it before open enrollment, not during.
4Ask about alternatives
Some small businesses now reimburse employees for individual health plans instead of offering a group plan, through arrangements called a QSEHRA or an ICHRA. They aren't right for everyone, but they're worth asking your broker about if group costs are getting out of reach.
Another option is a PEO, a company that handles payroll, benefits, and some HR for you as a "co-employer." Because a PEO groups employees from many businesses together, it can often offer plans and rates that are hard for a small company to get on its own. The tradeoffs are monthly fees, less control over plan choices, and a bigger lift if you ever decide to leave.
I've worked with PEOs through two of the big payroll companies. What I liked most was how much of the benefits work they took off my plate, since everything was built right into the HR system. But it was also the more expensive option, and most contracts locked us in for more than a year, which was frustrating. Whether a PEO is worth it really depends on the size of your company and what you need. Get a few quotes, and read the contract terms before you sign.
5Tell your employees early
In my experience, most employees don't understand their benefits at all. Deductibles, copays, and networks are confusing, and a price increase on top of that feels like a surprise. The worst way for an employee to learn their premium went up is on their first paycheck of the year. Tell them what's changing, why, and what you did to keep it manageable.
You don't have to explain it all yourself. Many brokers and carriers will host an open enrollment meeting for your employees, and some HR systems offer them too. They're often remote, so people can join from anywhere, and they're a great way for employees to ask questions directly.
After the meeting, give people a short summary they can come back to. I've hosted open enrollment meetings and created benefits summaries for a large company, and a clear one-pager answers more questions than any email thread.
6Know what's required, and what isn't
Federal law requires employers with 50 or more full-time employees, including equivalents, to offer affordable coverage or pay a penalty. If you're under 50, offering health insurance is a choice. It's still one of the most valued benefits you can offer, and often the one that decides whether a good candidate says yes.